Cow Milk Cheeses

Ours are made with fresh milk delivered daily from neighboring family-owned dairy farms, many of which have been providing the milk for Carr Valley cheeses for generations. Please check shipping map for appropriate delivery expectations. We will not ship out packages in the same week they are ordered if they will not be delivered by the weekend. Prices are listed per pound but will only charge for what you receive.

Apple Smoked Cheddar


Price: $11.15 per pound

Made in a 12# wheel. This white cheddar is apple smoked and then hand rubbed with paprika. It has a light smoky flavor that balances very well with the paprika. This cheese won 1st Place at the 2005 American Cheese Society in its category, 3rd Place at the 2006 World Cheese...[more]

Apple Smoked Garlic Cheddar


Price: $11.00 per pound

Apple Smoked Garlic Cheddar - with flavor that's so bold, deep and delicious, Sid says this cheese should be placed on the "Controlled Substance" list. One try, and we think you will agree! Recently took a Bronze Medal at the 2011 World Cheese Awards.

Bread Cheese


Price: $9.15 per pound

In Finland there is a cheese called Juustoleipa. This translates into cheese bread. We make ours different but better with oven baking it until it has a browned crusty top. Pop it in your oven or microwave until it glistens. Serve it with your favorite dip as a delicious...[more]

Chipotle Bread Cheese


Price: $9.15 per pound

Our signature Bread Cheese blended with chipotle peppers. Smoky and subtle heat from the chipotle brings the flavor of the best Texas barbecure to your taste buds. Serve warm with your favorite fruit, chutney, or salsa.

Garlic Bread Cheese


Price: $9.15 per pound

A mild, baked cheese with an authentic Italian garlic flavor....serve with fresh marinara sauce to create an outstanding appetizer. Saute or grill, until glistening or microwave for 30 seconds on high until warm.

Jalapeno Bread Cheese


Price: $9.15 per pound

Newly released Jalapeno Bread Cheese is here! Our outstanding Bread Cheese with an added punch! Green and red jalapeno peppers, with a spicy and toasty flavor! Cube and microwave for 30 seconds or saute in a skillet. Serve with your favorite dip as a delicious snack. Our...[more]

Cave Aged Cheddar


Price: $16.10 per pound

Wisconsin's only cave-aged Cheddar, this variety has a creamy color and distinctive rind that develops in the open-air cave, where natural molds flourish and add beautiful character to the cheese. Sid says its earthy flavor is reminiscent of the cheese his family made more...[more]



Price: $7.75 per pound

A Wisconsin original first made in Colby, Wisconsin. We make and age the original recipe with an open body creamy texture and a fresh cheesy flavor. This cheese won 2nd place in its class at the 2005 American Cheese Society Competition and first place at the 2006 American...[more]

Cranberry Cheddar


Price: $11.00 per pound

The Cranberry Cheddar is a gourmet beautiful artisan white cheddar that is accentuated with sweet Wisconsin cranberries. This lovely cheese would be an elegant addition to your favorite sandwich or cheese tray.

Cranberry Chipotle Cheddar


Price: $10.60 per pound

This white cheddar has cranberries and chipotle peppers for added flavor. It has the taste of the best Texas barbecue sauce and the heat comes on after the flavor of the cheese and has a very warm finish. Cranberry Chipotle Cheddar took 3rd Place at the 2007 U.S. Championship...[more]